Norwegian version of this page

MultiChina (completed)

How does Chinese economic engagement influence environmental and democratic governance in Africa and Latin America?

illustrasjon

About the project

Full name: Chinese Multilateralism and its Impact on Environmental and Democratic Governance in Africa and Latin America

The rise of China continues to shape the global order in many ways. One way is by changing the conditions of democratic and environmental governance, particularly in low-income countries.

This project studies how the scaling up of Chinese economic engagement influences democratic and natural resources governance in Africa and Latin America. How are the principles of cooperation between China and individual countries shaped and influenced? And how and to what extent are the principles of international organization and cooperation between groups of countries affected?

In order to respond to these questions, our focus is to study Chinese influence in Chile, Venezuela, Zimbabwe and Kenya. These cases have been selected based on differences in state capacity and the strength of democratic institutions. In addition, we will study the effects of Chinese engagement in four very different international organizational contexts. While two of these have been key institutions for international cooperation for several decades (the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) and the United Nations Department for Economic and Social Affairs, UNDESA), CELAC-China Forum and Forum for China and Africa Cooperation (FOCAC) are newer organizations established to strengthen the relationship between China and Latin America and Africa, respectively.

Objectives

Our primary objective is to explain the impact of the combined effect of Chinese bilateral and multilateral initiatives on norms of democratic and natural resource governance in Africa and Latin America.

Our secondary objectives are to:

  1. Describe China’s means to coordinate bilateral and multilateral, state and business initiatives
  2. Understand how Chinese initiatives influence multilateral norms in Africa and Latin America
  3. Analyze the conditions under which Chinese engagement influences elite composition, norms and attitudes
  4. Establish a solid environment for the study of implications of a Sino-centric multilateralism at SUM (UiO)
  5. Strengthen research collaboration between SUM (UiO), CIBE-UIBE and SCOT-UIBE (Beijing)
  6. Build a shared language for interpretation and reciprocal understanding between Norway-China
  7. Expand dialogue with stakeholders influencing China’s global outreach
  8. Strengthen Norway’s knowledge base to navigate a new international institutional context

Outcomes

We study Chinese influence through in-depth interviews with elites in China and in case countries and organizations, and by tracing the processes of Chinese engagement from initiation of cooperation projects to final completion. The results of this project will contribute to finding answers to pressing issues in global governance including: How will the large Chinese investment and lending program, the Belt and Road Initiative, influence the achievement of global goals on environment and development? To what extent is the increasing Chinese influence on global politics weakening democracies?

    Financing

    CHINOR Programme, The Research Council of Norway.

    Research news

    /english/research/interfaculty-research-areas/completed/sum/projects/multichina/index.html, 92:5: $​{include:feed}: /english/research/projects/multichina/research-news/?vrtx=feed does not exist

    Media

    /english/research/interfaculty-research-areas/completed/sum/projects/multichina/index.html, 96:5: $​{include:feed}: /english/research/projects/multichina/news/?vrtx=feed does not exist

    Publications

    /english/research/interfaculty-research-areas/completed/sum/projects/multichina/index.html, 100:5: $​{include:feed}: /english/research/projects/multichina/publications/?vrtx=feed does not exist

    Publications

    • Benedicte Bull & Antulio Rosales (2025). Chinese impact on development in Venezuela: the dynamics of structural stagnation. New Political Economy. ISSN 1356-3467. 31(1), p. 125–144. doi: 10.1080/13563467.2025.2531004. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull, Antulio Rosales & Manuel Sutherland (2025). Authoritarian Capitalism in Venezuela: The Political Economy of Maduro’s Disorderly Liberalization. In John Polga-Hecimovich & Sánchez-Urribarri Raúl (Ed.), Authoritarian Consolidation in Times of Crisis: Venezuela under Nicolás Maduro. Routledge. ISSN 9781032601670. p. 63–81. doi: 10.4324/9781003457886-5. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2025). Does the Rise of the Global South Weaken Democracy? The Pivotal Case of the 2024 Presidential Elections in Venezuela. Forum for Development Studies. ISSN 0803-9410. 52(2), p. 361–382. doi: 10.1080/08039410.2024.2424582. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull & Dan Banik (2025). The Rebirth of the Global South: Geopolitics, Imageries and Developmental Realities. Forum for Development Studies. ISSN 0803-9410. 52(2), p. 195–214. doi: 10.1080/08039410.2025.2490696. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2024). China and the New Geopolitics of Climate Multilateralism in Latin America. Iberoamericana – Nordic Journal of Latin American and Caribbean Studies. ISSN 0046-8444. 53(1), p. 44–58. doi: 10.16993/iberoamericana.633. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull & Antulio Rosales (2024). Elite Dynamics and China's Influence in Latin-America. Development and Change. ISSN 0012-155X. 55(5), p. 1206–1229. doi: 10.1111/dech.12861. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik & Emma Mawdsley (2023). Special Issue: China and India in Africa. Journal of International Development. ISSN 0954-1748. 35(4), p. 537–668. Full text in Research Archive
    • Bjorn Leif Brauteseth (2023). A Chinese Communist Party perspective on development and the environment: socialism through environmental development? Handbook of International Development and the Environment. Edward Elgar Publishing. ISSN 9781800883772. p. 100–120. doi: 10.4337/9781800883789. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2022). Caught in the Crossfire: The Inter-American Development Bank and US–China Rivalry. Global China Pulse. ISSN 2004-4607. 1(1). Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik & Benedicte Bull (2022). Multilateralism to the Rescue? Beijing’s Support for Multilateral Institutions during the COVID-19 Crisis. Internationales Asienforum. ISSN 0020-9449. 53(2). doi: 10.11588/iqas.2022.2.14102. Full text in Research Archive
    • Eric Cezne & Ulrikke Bryn Wethal (2022). Reading Mozambique's mega-project developmentalism through the workplace: Evidence from Chinese and Brazilian investments. African Affairs. ISSN 0001-9909. 121(484), p. 343–370. doi: 10.1093/afraf/adac019. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2022). Democracy and Sustainable Development. Anthropocene Science. ISSN 2731-3980. 1(1), p. 233–245. doi: 10.1007/s44177-022-00019-z. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2021). The 2030 agenda and the push for electrification in Africa: a tale of two countries, Environmental Sustainability and Economy. Elsevier. ISSN 9780128221884. Full text in Research Archive

    View all works in NVA

    View all works in NVA

    • Benedicte Bull (2025). Ekko: Panamakanalen. [Radio]. P2. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2025). USAs utenriksminister Marco Rubio besøker Panama. Her er fem spørsmål og svar. [Journal]. Aftenposten. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2025). USA truer med «nødvendige tiltak» i Panama: –⁠ Denne situasjonen er uakseptabel. [Journal]. VG. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2025). Latin-Amerika i en ny global (u)orden. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2025). BRICS: solidaritet i sør eller Kinas og Russlands ekkokammer? Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2025). Debatten: Trump vil ta tilbake Panama kanalen. [TV]. NRK1. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2025). Chinas Changing Presence in Latin America: What does it mean for development and regional cooperation, seminar for EU diplomats. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2024). Las elites politicas desde América Latina. [Radio]. Podcst de Anselmo Flores Andrade. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2024). Hvorfor stemmer så mange velgere i verden på autoritære menn? [Journal]. Forskning.no. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2024). Podcast: Demokrati i krise. [Radio]. Litteraturhusets podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2024). The US-China Partnership That Transformed International Trade — Elizabeth Ingleson. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development Podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2024). Democracy in the Balance: Navigating Latin America's Political Landscape — Gerardo Munck. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development Podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2024). Voices and Votes: Shaping the Democratic Landscape in Africa — Boniface Dulani. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development Podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2024). Rising Powers and the New Global Order — Rohan Mukherjee. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development Podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2024). Shifting Paradigms: The Global South and Feminist Political Economy Unveiled — Sara Stevano. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development Podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2024). Beyond Trade: China's Cultural and Political Relations in Africa – Joshua Eisenman. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development Podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2024). Infrastructure, Governance, and Society in Modern Africa — Karuti Kanyinga. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development Podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2024). Great Power Competition and the Global South — Ilaria Carrozza. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development Podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2024). The Future of Industrialization – Jostein Hauge. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development Podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2024). Forum 60 +: BRICS: Solidaritet i sør eller Kina og Russlands ekkokammer? Full text in Research Archive
    • Michael Chasukwa & Dan Banik (2024). Development Aid: Complementarity or Competition? The West and China in Malawi. In Hopestone Chavula, Thomas Chataghalala Munthali, Harold P. E. Ngalawa & Boniface Dulani (Ed.), The Oxford Handbook of the Malawi Economy. Oxford University Press. ISSN 9780198890164. p. 121–140. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2024). ¿Puede el capitalismo autoritario resolver los problemas de América Latina? Pensamiento Iberoamericano. ISSN 0212-0208. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2024). Xi knytter stadig sterke bånd i Latin-Amerika – Trump får noe av skylden. [Internet]. ABC Nyheter. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2024). Under trusler fra Trump øker Kinas innflytelse i Latin-Amerika. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2024). China y la Unión Europea en la transición verde en America Latina. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2024). China and the New Geopolitics of Climate Change Multilateralism in Latin America. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2024). Conversatorio Guangzhou: Hacía donde va la relación China-América Latina. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2024). Venezuela: Demokratihåpet som brast. Hvor hender det?. ISSN 0801-9509. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2024). Kinas endrede tilstedeværese i Latin-Amerika: Multilateralisme og utvikling, foredrag for Utenriksdepartementet. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik & Emma Mawdsley (2023). South–South Cooperation and global development in a multipolar world: China and India in Africa. Journal of International Development. ISSN 0954-1748. 35(4), p. 539–548. doi: 10.1002/jid.3789. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2023). Unpacking the Backlash Against Globalization and its Impact on Inequality – Pinelopi Koujianou Goldberg. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development Podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2023). Decoding Development: The Crucial Role of Institutions – Shiping Tang. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development Podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2023). Urix på lørdag: Kina, Russland og Latin-Amerika. [Radio]. NRK P2. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2023). Nei, Kina har ikke kontroll på kontinentet Rykker Kina virkelig inn i USAs bakgård? Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2023). The World Stage: Does BRICS expansion signify conflict between the West and the rest? [Internet]. NUPI Podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2023). India vs Kina (Panellist). Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2023). La rivalidad entre los EEUU y China y el impacto en Chile y América Latina. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2023). Banking on Beijing — Axel Dreher. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2023). Poverty and the new threat to prosperity — Indermit Gill. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2023). Chile: Spydspiss i en ny, aktiv alliansefrihet? In Vegard Bye & Olle Törnquist (Ed.), Gjenreising av det globale fellesskapet: Hvor ble det av solidariteten?. Forlaget Kolon. ISSN 9788230026229. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2023). Dagens P1: Rekordmye kokain fra Latin-Amerika. [Radio]. NRKP1. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2023). Otra visión de China. El Grand Continent. ISSN 2824-1495. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2023). En bekymringsmelding fra Latin-Amerika Vesten mister Latin-Amerika. Det haster å gjøre noe med det. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2023). How China's digital entrepreneurs are redefining innovation and reshaping the global economy — Lin Zhang. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2023). The Politics of Poverty in a Changing World Order: Challenges, Strategies, and Promising Practices. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2023). Forging New Paths in Challenging Geopolitical Landscapes — Stephen D. Krasner. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2023). Vesten bør ønske Latin-Amerika velkommen som en mulig uavhengig deltager i global politikk. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2023). América Latina y la UE: geopolítica entre Rusia y China. [Internet]. Deutche Welle. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2023). Ikkje på lag med Vesten: Latin-Amerika. [Journal]. Klassekampen. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull & Aslak Jangård Orre (2022). MultiChina seminar: Will China Come to the Rescue? Post-Pandemic Crises and the Role of China in Latin America and Africa. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2022). The development bargain — Stefan Dercon. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2022). Global morgen: Latin-Amerika i en ny verdensorden. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2022). Vindu mot verden: Venezuela og Chile i en ny verdensorden. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull & Dan Banik (2022). MultiChina Seminar: A changing face of China in Latin America and Africa: From economic statecraft to complex multilateralism? Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2022). Africa's right to development — Mo Ibrahim. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2022). Breaking Bad: Understanding Backlash Against Democracy in Africa — Lise Rakner. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2022). Globalization and Asian Geopolitics — Shivshankar Menon. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2022). Global morgen: Latin-Amerika i en ny verdensorden. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2022). Verden sett fra Latin-Amerika. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2022). The power of the Chinese state: Examination, Autocracy, Stability, and Technology — Yasheng Huang. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2022). Great power rivalry and regional cooperation in Latin America: From US-led to Chinese dominated multilateralism? Full text in Research Archive
    • Wei Guo (2022). Chinese Multilateralism and its Impact on Environmental and Democratic Governance in Africa and Latin America (MultiChina) project introduction. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2022). A New Narrative on Africa. [Internet]. NUPI. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2022). Green finance in the Global South – can it help combat climate change and aid sustainable development? [Internet]. NUPI. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull & Dan Banik (2021). MultiChina Webinar: BRI and SDG: Chinese lenders’ credit policy and practice. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2021). Francis Fukuyama on political development and political decay. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development Podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2021). Et geopolitisk veivalg med miljøet som innsats. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2021). Baksiden av det grønne skiftet: Kampen om Latin-Amerikas litium. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2021). The Chinese approach to network-building. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2021). The impact of the sustainable development concept — Frank Biermann. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development Podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2021). Reimagining development — Hannah Ryder. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development Podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2021). The remarkable expansion of South–South Cooperation — Emma Mawdsley. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development Podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2021). Summit diplomacy and African agency — Folashadé Soulé. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development Podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Benedicte Bull (2021). China and Latin America in the post-Trump era. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2021). Beating the Odds: Jump-Starting Developing Countries — Justin Yifu Lin. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2021). Local resistance against coal in Lamu, Kenya — Raya Ahmed, Omar Elmawi, Gino Cocchiaro. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2021). Living in a Materials World: Extractives on the road to Net Zero — Tony Addison. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2021). Is it the end of democracy in Africa? — Nic Cheeseman. [Internet]. In Pursuit of Development. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2020). Yuen Yuen Ang on economic boom, poverty reduction and corruption in China. [Radio]. In Pursuit of Development Podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2020). Global inequality and the future of capitalism -- Branko Milanovic. [Radio]. In Pursuit of Development Podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2020). Liu Baocheng on what the West does not understand about China. [Radio]. In Pursuit of Development Podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2020). Crises and leadership. [Radio]. In Pursuit of Development Podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2020). China in a post-Covid world. [Radio]. In Pursuit of Development Podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2020). Benedicte Bull on state capacity in Latin America. [Radio]. In Pursuit of Development Podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2020). Gyude Moore on China’s Belt and Road Initiative and infrastructure development in Africa. [Radio]. In Pursuit of Development Podcast. Full text in Research Archive
    • Dan Banik (2020). Eric Olander on China-Africa relations. [Radio]. In Pursuit of Development Podcast. Full text in Research Archive

    View all works in NVA

    Published Aug. 7, 2020 12:13 PM - Last modified Aug. 13, 2025 8:08 PM

    Participants

    Detailed list of participants